When Homestead Passes to the Children and One of Them Won't Sell

The home was worth about $480,000 when the mother died, and it was the only significant asset she owned. She had been widowed for years, and her will left everything to her three adult children in equal shares. Her son had moved in during her last two years to help care for her, and his sisters were grateful for it at the time. 

Eighteen months later he is still living there. His sisters have been sharing the cost of taxes and insurance on a house none of them can use, and he has turned down every proposal to list the property or buy out their interests. The personal representative, one of the daughters, assumed she could sell the home as part of the administration and has since learned that she cannot. 

Florida’s homestead rules explain why she cannot, and they also point to the proceeding that resolves the impasse. 

How Homestead Title Passes at Death 

Article X, section 4(c) of the Florida Constitution restricts the devise of homestead only when the owner is survived by a spouse or a minor child. An owner survived by neither may leave the home by will, and in Snyder v. Davis, 699 So. 2d 999 (Fla. 1997), the Florida Supreme Court held that a devisee within the class of persons who could take by intestacy receives the home with its constitutional protection from the owner’s creditors intact. Where there is no will, section 732.103 passes the property to the decedent’s descendants. 

In either case, a home that passes to several children vests in them at death as co-owners, each holding an undivided share of the whole and each entitled to possession of all of it. The homestead provisions give no single heir the right to decide what happens to the property. 

Why the Personal Representative Cannot Sell It 

Sections 733.607 and 733.608 except protected homestead from the property a personal representative takes into possession and controls for paying expenses and making distributions. Section 733.608(2) permits a personal representative to take possession of a homestead that no interested person occupies, solely to preserve and protect it while its status is unresolved. 

In Harrell v. Snyder, 913 So. 2d 749 (Fla. 5th DCA 2005), the Fifth District affirmed a personal representative’s possession of protected homestead under that subsection and reversed the order to the extent it authorized her to sell the property, finding no statutory authority for a sale. Title insurers commonly require an order determining homestead status under Florida Probate Rule 5.405 before insuring a conveyance, and that order identifies by name each person entitled to the property and the interest each holds. 

Partition Among Co-Owners 

When the persons named in that order cannot agree, chapter 64 supplies the remedy. Section 64.031 allows joint tenants and tenants in common to have partition, and where a property cannot be divided among its owners without prejudice to them, as with a single-family home, the court may order it sold and the proceeds divided according to each owner’s interest. 

Section 64.081 addresses the cost of that proceeding. It apportions attorney’s fees and costs among the parties according to their interests and as the court finds equitable, and it permits the court to direct that those amounts be paid from the proceeds of a sale. 

Where a Surviving Spouse Fits 

A surviving spouse alters the analysis. When a married owner dies leaving descendants, section 732.401 gives the spouse a life estate and the descendants a vested remainder. Those are successive interests, and in Barden v. Pappas, 532 So. 2d 707 (Fla. 5th DCA 1988), the Fifth District held that a life tenant cannot maintain partition against remaindermen, because partition is a remedy among owners whose interests exist at the same time. 

The same statute gives the spouse a choice. Within six months of the decedent’s death, the spouse may record an election to take an undivided one-half interest as a tenant in common, with the other half vesting in the descendants. The election is irrevocable, and once it is made, the spouse and the descendants hold concurrent interests to which partition applies. 

What This Means for Drafting and Litigation Practices

For a drafting practice, a home left in equal shares to several children is one of the most common sources of this deadlock, especially when one child already lives there. Provisions addressing occupancy, a buyout, or a sale, along with the choice of whether the home passes by will or through a trust, each shape how title passes and what the family can do with the property afterward. 

For a litigation practice, the homestead determination and the partition action run as separate proceedings with their own parties and timelines. An administration can be complete as to every other asset while the home remains titled in the heirs and unresolved. 

Where This Overlaps with Other Claims 

Disputes over the family home seldom arrive alone. A deed signed late in the owner’s life may have moved the property out of the estate before death, which raises undue influence or capacity questions of its own, and uncertainty over who qualifies as a descendant may call for a determination of beneficiaries before anyone knows who the co-owners are. 

For Referring Attorneys 

The matters we see most often involve a family home of meaningful value, either no surviving spouse or a spouse who elected a one-half interest, and one heir in possession who will not agree to a sale. The heirs on the outside usually have little liquidity, since the house holds most of what their parent left them, and that makes a partition action difficult to fund by the hour. When a client is in that position, send us the matter. We handle these cases on a contingent-fee basis, and referral fees up to 25 percent are available. 

For Families

If a parent’s home passed to you and your siblings, and one of them is living there and refusing to sell, Florida law gives you a way to ask a court to order the sale. You do not need money set aside for legal fees to explore it. Harrison Estate Law reviews these situations at no charge, and when we take a case there are no fees or costs unless we recover for you. Call our office or reach us through harrisonestatelaw.com to speak with our probate litigation team.

When Homestead Passes to the Children and One of Them Won't Sell

The home was worth about $480,000 when the mother died, and it was the only significant asset she owned. She had been widowed for years, and her will left everything to her three adult children in equal shares. Her son had moved in during her last two years to help care for her, and his sisters were grateful for it at the time. 

Eighteen months later he is still living there. His sisters have been sharing the cost of taxes and insurance on a house none of them can use, and he has turned down every proposal to list the property or buy out their interests. The personal representative, one of the daughters, assumed she could sell the home as part of the administration and has since learned that she cannot. 

Florida’s homestead rules explain why she cannot, and they also point to the proceeding that resolves the impasse. 

How Homestead Title Passes at Death 

Article X, section 4(c) of the Florida Constitution restricts the devise of homestead only when the owner is survived by a spouse or a minor child. An owner survived by neither may leave the home by will, and in Snyder v. Davis, 699 So. 2d 999 (Fla. 1997), the Florida Supreme Court held that a devisee within the class of persons who could take by intestacy receives the home with its constitutional protection from the owner’s creditors intact. Where there is no will, section 732.103 passes the property to the decedent’s descendants. 

In either case, a home that passes to several children vests in them at death as co-owners, each holding an undivided share of the whole and each entitled to possession of all of it. The homestead provisions give no single heir the right to decide what happens to the property. 

Why the Personal Representative Cannot Sell It 

Sections 733.607 and 733.608 except protected homestead from the property a personal representative takes into possession and controls for paying expenses and making distributions. Section 733.608(2) permits a personal representative to take possession of a homestead that no interested person occupies, solely to preserve and protect it while its status is unresolved. 

In Harrell v. Snyder, 913 So. 2d 749 (Fla. 5th DCA 2005), the Fifth District affirmed a personal representative’s possession of protected homestead under that subsection and reversed the order to the extent it authorized her to sell the property, finding no statutory authority for a sale. Title insurers commonly require an order determining homestead status under Florida Probate Rule 5.405 before insuring a conveyance, and that order identifies by name each person entitled to the property and the interest each holds. 

Partition Among Co-Owners 

When the persons named in that order cannot agree, chapter 64 supplies the remedy. Section 64.031 allows joint tenants and tenants in common to have partition, and where a property cannot be divided among its owners without prejudice to them, as with a single-family home, the court may order it sold and the proceeds divided according to each owner’s interest. 

Section 64.081 addresses the cost of that proceeding. It apportions attorney’s fees and costs among the parties according to their interests and as the court finds equitable, and it permits the court to direct that those amounts be paid from the proceeds of a sale. 

Where a Surviving Spouse Fits 

A surviving spouse alters the analysis. When a married owner dies leaving descendants, section 732.401 gives the spouse a life estate and the descendants a vested remainder. Those are successive interests, and in Barden v. Pappas, 532 So. 2d 707 (Fla. 5th DCA 1988), the Fifth District held that a life tenant cannot maintain partition against remaindermen, because partition is a remedy among owners whose interests exist at the same time. 

The same statute gives the spouse a choice. Within six months of the decedent’s death, the spouse may record an election to take an undivided one-half interest as a tenant in common, with the other half vesting in the descendants. The election is irrevocable, and once it is made, the spouse and the descendants hold concurrent interests to which partition applies. 

What This Means for Drafting and Litigation Practices 

For a drafting practice, a home left in equal shares to several children is one of the most common sources of this deadlock, especially when one child already lives there. Provisions addressing occupancy, a buyout, or a sale, along with the choice of whether the home passes by will or through a trust, each shape how title passes and what the family can do with the property afterward. 

For a litigation practice, the homestead determination and the partition action run as separate proceedings with their own parties and timelines. An administration can be complete as to every other asset while the home remains titled in the heirs and unresolved. 

Where This Overlaps with Other Claims 

Disputes over the family home seldom arrive alone. A deed signed late in the owner’s life may have moved the property out of the estate before death, which raises undue influence or capacity questions of its own, and uncertainty over who qualifies as a descendant may call for a determination of beneficiaries before anyone knows who the co-owners are. 

For Referring Attorneys 

The matters we see most often involve a family home of meaningful value, either no surviving spouse or a spouse who elected a one-half interest, and one heir in possession who will not agree to a sale. The heirs on the outside usually have little liquidity, since the house holds most of what their parent left them, and that makes a partition action difficult to fund by the hour. When a client is in that position, send us the matter. We handle these cases on a contingent-fee basis, and referral fees up to 25 percent are available. 

For Families

If a parent’s home passed to you and your siblings, and one of them is living there and refusing to sell, Florida law gives you a way to ask a court to order the sale. You do not need money set aside for legal fees to explore it. Harrison Estate Law reviews these situations at no charge, and when we take a case there are no fees or costs unless we recover for you. Call our office or reach us through harrisonestatelaw.com to speak with our probate litigation team.